1A Docket First Amendment · Utah
Utah Supreme Court · 2026 UT 7, 587 P.3d 981

Aston v. Chronicle-Progress LLC

Granted in part UPEPA
Forum
Utah Supreme Court
Case number
2026 UT 7, 587 P.3d 981
Motion decided
Apr 2, 2026
Outcome
Granted in part
Conduct at issue
Newspaper reporting on a developer's history of failed business deals and bankruptcies
Underlying claims
Defamation

Docket · filings

Apr 16, 2024 DefendantMotion for expedited relief PDF
May 28, 2024 PlaintiffReply in opposition PDF
Jun 18, 2024 DefendantReply in support PDF
Sep 24, 2024 CourtDistrict court ruling PDF
Oct 17, 2024 DefendantMotion for attorney fees, costs, and expenses PDF
Oct 31, 2024 PlaintiffMemorandum in opposition to the fee motion PDF
Nov 14, 2024 DefendantReply in support of the fee motion PDF
Dec 23, 2024 CourtOrder granting the motion for attorney fees, costs, and expenses PDF
Apr 2, 2026 Utah Supreme CourtOpinion PDF

What the court held

  • On first impression the court held that the phrase related to the motion in Section 78B-25-110 limits recovery to expenses reasonably necessary to prosecute the special motion, not the entire litigation.
  • The district court had granted the motion and awarded roughly $394,000 covering essentially all work in the case, without a task-by-task analysis.
  • Remanded for recalculation.